“Miscellanies,” x. PLEASANTNESS OF RELIGION

Ongoing work on Edwards’s Miscellanies. Share entries, reflections, and insights from the JESociety Miscellanies Companion project.


Post Reply
User avatar
Rob Boss
Site Admin
Posts: 46
Joined: Fri Jul 17, 2026 3:30 pm
Location: Fort Worth, TX
Contact:

“Miscellanies,” x. PLEASANTNESS OF RELIGION

Post by Rob Boss »

%%{init: { "theme": "base", "themeVariables": { "mindmapRootColor": "#2F3A2A", "mindmapTextColor": "#ffffff", "mindmapMainColor": "#D4A017", "mindmapSecondaryColor": "#8FB46E", "mindmapLineColor": "#B38B0F", "primaryColor": "#D4A017", "primaryTextColor": "#ffffff", "secondaryColor": "#8FB46E" } }}%% mindmap root((Pleasantness of Religion)) No Argument Against It Does NOT raise laughter Actually tends to remove laughter Nature of Laughter Never great pleasure Flashy, external & short-lived Arises from mixture of pleasure + sorrow Comes from what is ridiculous Mixture of pleasant + painful Something deformed / contrary to beautiful True Pleasure Purely agreeable → No laughter Raises a sweet smile (not grimace) At its height → Face shines with joy Like the joy of dear friends Why Religion Doesn't Always Produce a Smile Because of our sins Offended God Religious thoughts mixed with repentance Sense of our own misery Pleasure of repentance itself does not tend to smile Why Religious Thoughts Cause Sighs NOT from melancholy of religion From high, internal, spiritual nature Abstracts soul from body Deadens bodily operations Causes sigh to renew the body At greatest height Soul in a trance Body left nearly dead

Source: WJE 175–76

Attachments
visual-edwards-diagram-2.png
visual-edwards-diagram-2.png (217.79 KiB) Viewed 1737 times

Robert L. Boss, PhD
Director | JESociety

Post Reply